Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 3/1.
Sutter's Mill
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Gallery
  • Gift Cards
  • About
  • Holiday Info
  • Covid Information
sm
MenuKids MenuFamily Meals
Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Menu

Appetizers

Sutter's Mill Garlic Toast

$3

6 pcs of our hand cut sourdough bread toasted and topped with out house made garlic butter

1 review
 

Shrimp Cocktail Supreme

$9

3 jumbo shrimp cut into bite size pcs in our zesty cocktail sauce

 

Sautéed Mushrooms

$3

great as an appetizer or with your entrée

11 pop3 reviews
 

Melted Cheese Toast

$5

6 pcs of our garlic toast topped with cheddar cheese

112 pops1 review
 

Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

$7

Jumbo mushroom caps sautéed in garlic butter, topped with crab and parmesan cheese

11 pop2 reviews
 

Entrées

All entrées are served with a salad (choice of dressing) & 
choice of a side: baked potato (stuffed or plain), french fries or mac n' cheese

Ground Beef Steak

$15

10oz ground beef hand formed in house

1 review
 

BBQ Pork Ribs

$18

A one lb. full rack slow cooked and finished on the grill

11 pop1 review
 

Wally Burger

$11

two 5 oz patties stuffed with cheddar cheese served on a sesame seed bun with tomato, lettuce and pickle on the side

1 review
 

Chicken Piccata

$13

Boneless skinless chicken breast sliced thin & sautéed with lemon, garlic, mushrooms & capers

1 review
 

Garden Salad

$10

Iceberg & romaine lettuce with tomato, cucumber, sliced mushrooms, green onions, avacado, bacon bits, cheddar cheese and served with a slice of garlic toast.

Sliced 8 oz chicken breast +$4
11 pop2 reviews
 

Cheeseburger

$9

A 5oz. patty topped with American cheese, served on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato and pickles on the side

 

Hamburger

$8

A 5oz. patty served on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato and pickles on the side

 

Sutter's Prime Rib

Our Most Popular Entrée 
Slow roasted for exceptional tenderness and flavor. 
(limited availability * first come first serve)

8oz Cut

$21
44 pops8 reviews
 

Prime Rib Sandwich

$19

6oz thin sliced on our garlic toast

11 pop6 reviews
 

12oz Cut

$26
112 pops12 reviews
 

Steaks

Our steaks are seasoned lightly with garlic. 
We will gladly further season your steak on request.

Top Sirloin

$17

8 oz. USDA Prime Top Sirloin
A favorite since 1958

7 reviews
 

Rib Eye

$23

12 oz. hand cut in house

11 pop5 reviews
 

Filet Mignon

$24

8 oz. barrel cut

11 pop6 reviews
 

Seafood

Deep Fried Shrimp

$16

4 pcs jumbo breaded shrimp served with our zesty cocktail sauce

1 review
 

Maine Lobster Tail

$32

10 - 12 oz cold water tail

3 reviews
 

Salmon Fillet

$15

8 oz fillet topped with teriyaki or lemon/garlic/ caper sauce

2 reviews
 

10 oz Alaskan King Crab

$39

10 oz. of the thickest part of the leg

11 pop5 reviews
 

Create a combo

Add any of the following items to an entrée

Maine Lobster Tail

$24

10 - 12 oz cold water tail

3 reviews
 

10 oz Alaskan King Crab

$29
11 pop5 reviews
 

Deep Fried Shrimp

$8

3 pcs jumbo breaded shrimp served with our zesty cocktail sauce

1 review
 

1/2 Maine Lobster Tail

$18

5 - 6 oz cold water lobster

5 reviews
 

1 lb Alaskan King Crab

$45
1 review
 

Dessert

Peach Cobbler

$4

Made in house

Ice Cream +$2
11 pop2 reviews
 

Cheesecake

$4
Top with Strawberries +$1
 

Cherry Cobbler

$4

Made in house

Ice Cream +$2
1 review
 

Chocolate Cake

$5
Ice Cream +$2
 

* All weights listed are for comparison purposes only. Actual weights may vary.
* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses

Made with by Popmenu
Sutter's Mill
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window