Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Sutter's Mill. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Filet Mignon
Wow! One of the best steaks I ever had. Same class as Flemming's and Larsen's and Mastro's! Had it three times and each time it was consistently great!
Rib Eye
I just wanted to thank the staff at Sutters Mill during the first few months of lockdown. My husband & I both have severe compromised health conditions. Marie made it that when we ordered our food, it was delivered. Time went on & we were able to eventually pick it up. I've never forgotten Marie & staff taking care of us. Today we ordered my birthday dinner & as always the food was delicious. The best blue cheese dressing too! Can't wait for the next time! Thank you, Vicki & Rich Noll
Sautéed Mushrooms
Always a must have with ground beef steak or Wally burger
8oz Cut
Always can count on a good, reasonable priced dinner, with great service. Thank you to the whole staff. See you next time.
Top Sirloin
I am always leery of top sirloin BUT and please take note this is the best you will ever have! Flavor is unbeatable. Baked potato side of garlic toast soup or salad both delicious. Their salad dressings are known everywhere. I have seen people come in and buy the dressing. Yep no kidding. Best honey mustard I've ever had.
Salmon Fillet
The Salmon is always delicious along with green beans, stuffed baked potato and salad with house ranch dressing. We love coming for a date night. Every server goes out of their way to make our dining experience special. Our thanks to everyone at Sutter's. Terry
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
Lobster Tail, filet Mignon, and stuffed potato ... fantastically delicious! Each bite was tasty. My favorite to go place for celebrations. This time was for my birthday
Maine Lobster Tail
The lobster is amazing! Fresh, cooked perfectly. It's the perfect size I don't share! Lol choice of sides, a glass of wine, great service, the perfect dinner! I'm planning on it for my 65th on 8/12!
12oz Cut
My wife and I had come here last year 2019 and loved everything about our experience. We since then have introduced our Brother and Sister in-laws and we both agree it's the best prime rib we've ever had. Thanks.
1 lb Alaskan King Crab
Wonderful and very tender. Always good food no matter what you order.
12oz Cut
Auright! I have had the Miners cut everytime!! I can't stress enough how incredibly awesome this Prime Rib is! It literally melts in your mouth! The Horseradish plus the au jus makes the perfect compliment! And then the stuffed potatoe is as good as it possibly could be. Also the green beans almost completes this fantastic meal because their blue cheese dressing is by far the best I've had with the salad that also comes with it!! Never disappoints!! I highly recommend this meal!
Prime Rib Sandwich
Very tender and tasty Prime Rib accompanied by with Au Jus and a yummy Mac n Cheese. The garlic Cheese toast app was delicious. I will definitely be coming by more often Sutter's Mill.
Peach Cobbler
Absolutely delicious! My new favorite!
12oz Cut
I ordered the 12 ounce prime rib because I wasn't sure if the 8 ounce prime rib would fill me up, I had a delicious salad with it and it came with a Loaded baked potato & small portion of Green beans. The prime rib was Great 👍 . I was so full but next time I will order the 8 ounce so I have room for dessert.
Vanilla Ice Cream
Sutter's Mill vanilla ice cream has a wonderfully rich flavor, and the serving is generous. Perfect on its own, cobblers a la mode, and chocolate cake. We haven't tried it with the cheesecake yet.
Cherry Cobbler
We love the cobblers! There's enough to share, but it's always tough to decide between the cherry and peach. Try them both, with ice cream!
10 oz Alaskan King Crab
King crab was delicious ! It was an add-on to the Lobster tail.... which was also delicious ! This was my first time dining "out" in many months~thank you Sutter's for the good experience! Sutter's is doing their best with all the new guidelines.
Rib Eye
I had the Rib Eye and added 3 shrimp and my wife had the Salmon. Both were excellent. Extremely friendly staff and the fact that they do not charge for corkage is Bonus! I can't wait to go back and work my way down the menu.
1/2 Maine Lobster Tail
We ordered a steak and added the lobster tail. Both were delish! And the sides too. Can't wait to dine in soon.
Wally Burger
Excellent, this has been my Dad's favorite for almost 60 years. Whenever he comes to Southern California it's what he has to have. Thank you for keeping it on the menu for those of us who have enjoyed Sutter's Mill since the 60's
Rib Eye
The best Rib Eye, perfect every time. And of course the martinis hit the spot! We are now at the point where we crave a Sutter's Mill outing way too often but with their price point how can you not cave in?!
Prime Rib Sandwich
This may be one of my favorite things on the menu besides the seafood which is always cooked perfect. Side of creamy horseradish and sour cream, perfectly crisp French fries.
8oz Cut
It was cooked perfectly and went perfectly with the fresh salad and mac and cheese. I can't wait to try something new.
Top Sirloin
My go to steak, always cooked to perfection! Paired with a stuffed baked potato it's my favorite meal! However... the prime rib is pretty awesome too!
1/2 Maine Lobster Tail
Sutter's lobster dinner was exquisite, flavorful, tender, aromatic with a wonderful butter accompaniment. Hmmm!
Top Sirloin
Delicious steak and cooked to perfection just as ordered!
12oz Cut
Loved the Prime Rib as it was tender and very flavorful! The Salads, Green Beans were delicious. Great portions!
Rib Eye
Amazing dinner for 2 that really is memorable.
Prime Rib Sandwich
Love it ... So delicious.....
Top Sirloin
Always a great cut ...and I try to go once a week. The staff goes above qnd beyond even if I make a change to my order. I go alot for reason...its great! And the staff makes it nice as well
Prime Rib Sandwich
The prime rib sandwich was absolutely delicious! It was so tender and juicy and packed with flavor. I order it every time now!! Sutters Mill has become a family favorite
8oz Cut
I love their prime rib. It's so juicy and tender! Hands down one of the best. Love that their corkage is free❤️
Peach Cobbler
We love the cobblers! There's enough to share, but it's always tough to decide between the peach and cherry. Try them both, with ice cream!
Garden Salad
We love these fresh salads with Sutter's Mills house dressings (try the bleu cheese!). The garlic bread is delicious too! Often we'll add a cup of soup or a stuffed potato because they're just so good!
Sutter's Mill Garlic Toast
Sutters Mill is a hidden gem in Simi Valley! Their Garlic Toast is truly the BRST!
Top Sirloin
Had the sirloin with a wedge salad. The steak was great & the salad was especially delicious! Very fresh, really enjoyed the meal.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
August 2020:
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA
July 2020:
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos
Colorado
June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL
May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY
April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA
January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC
December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL
November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA
October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR
September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA
July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY
June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY
April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA